Can Black Holes Split in Two? New Research Explores the Possibility
A new theoretical study published in Physical Review D explores whether black holes could fragment into smaller black holes under exceptional conditions. Rapid rotation, the laws of thermodynamics and the possibility of detecting Hawking radiation could hold the key.
By Zemeghub Science Desk | November 19, 2026
Can black holes split in two? For decades, scientists have understood that black holes can merge, creating larger and more massive objects. But splitting into two smaller black holes has traditionally been considered extremely unlikely, as it appears to conflict with one of the fundamental principles of physics: the second law of thermodynamics.
Now, a new theoretical study published in Physical Review D explores whether rapidly rotating black holes could overcome this apparent barrier under exceptionally extreme conditions. The research, titled When Black Holes Admit Pair-of-Pants Topologies, investigates a fascinating possibility: a black hole spinning close to its theoretical maximum could potentially fragment into smaller black holes.
If such an event occurred, the smallest fragments might eventually evaporate through Hawking radiation, potentially producing gamma rays that future observations or existing space telescopes could investigate. It is an extraordinary idea, but one that remains theoretical. No black hole has ever been observed splitting into two. To understand why scientists are taking this possibility seriously, we first need to understand why black holes normally merge rather than divide.
Can Black Holes Split in Two? Why Merging Is Easier Than Splitting
Black holes are among the most extreme objects in the known universe. Their gravitational fields are so powerful that, beyond a boundary known as the event horizon, nothing can escapeโnot even light. When two black holes approach each other, they can orbit one another, lose energy through gravitational waves and eventually merge into a single, more massive object.
This process has been observed repeatedly by the LIGO and Virgo gravitational-wave observatories, with KAGRA also contributing to the international detection network. Splitting, however, presents a very different problem. The obstacle is closely connected to one of the fundamental principles of physics: the second law of thermodynamics. This law tells us that the total entropy of an isolated system cannot decrease. Entropy is often described as disorder, although in physics it has a more precise meaning related to the number of possible microscopic configurations of a system.
Black holes have entropy too. According to the Bekenstein-Hawking formula, a black hole’s entropy is proportional to the area of its event horizon:
S = kแตฆcยณA / 4Gโ
In simple terms, the larger the horizon area, the greater the black hole’s entropy. For a non-rotating black hole, the horizon radius is proportional to its mass. Consequently, its entropy grows approximately with the square of its mass. This creates a serious problem for fragmentation.
Imagine a black hole with a certain mass breaking into two smaller black holes. If the original mass is simply distributed between the two fragments, their combined entropy would generally be lower than the entropy of the original object. That would mean a decrease in total black-hole entropy. Under the standard assumptions of classical general relativity, this makes the process thermodynamically unfavourable.
Merging is different: combining two black holes into a larger one can increase the total horizon area and therefore the total entropy. Nature appears to favour that direction.
The surprising role of rotation
The new research explores whether rapid rotation could change the situation. Black holes are not necessarily motionless objects. Some rotate at extraordinary speeds, dragging the surrounding spacetime along with them through an effect known as frame dragging. Rotating black holes are described by the Kerr solution, one of the most important exact solutions of Einstein’s field equations. Unlike a non-rotating black hole, a rotating one has a different relationship between mass, angular momentum, horizon area and entropy.
For a given mass, increasing the spin reduces the black hole’s entropy. This opens an interesting theoretical possibility: some of the original black hole’s rotational energy and angular momentum could be transferred into the motion of the resulting fragments.
In principle, that transfer could make a fragmentation scenario compatible with the entropy requirement. But there is an important complication. It is not enough for two smaller black holes to form mathematically. They must also have enough energy and momentum to move away from each other. If they cannot separate, they may simply fall back together. According to the researchers’ analysis, this additional kinematic requirement makes fragmentation much more difficult. The possibility survives mainly in configurations involving black holes rotating extremely close to their theoretical maximum.
In other words, rotation may open a narrow theoretical window, but it does not make black hole splitting a common or established astrophysical process.
A black hole wearing a pair of trousers?
One of the most unusual aspects of the research is its title. The expression pair-of-pants topology comes from the shape that would describe the evolution of a black hole horizon if one connected horizon divided into two. Picture a pair of trousers. The waist represents the original black hole. The two legs represent the two smaller black holes that would exist later.
If we could trace the geometry of the horizon through time, the resulting structure would resemble a pair of trousers. This is not simply a visual metaphor. Topology is the branch of mathematics concerned with the properties of shapes that remain unchanged under continuous deformation. In this case, the researchers use the idea to examine how the structure of a black hole horizon might change.
The distinction is important: the study investigates conditions under which fragmentation could be permitted in certain theoretical descriptions. It does not provide a complete physical mechanism demonstrating how an ordinary black hole would spontaneously divide.
Could primordial black holes be more likely to split?
The research also raises an intriguing possibility involving primordial black holes. Unlike ordinary astrophysical black holes, which form through processes such as the collapse of massive stars or mergers, primordial black holes are hypothetical objects that may have formed in the extremely dense and energetic conditions of the early universe. They could have a much wider range of masses than black holes produced by stellar evolution.
Their possible existence is particularly interesting because they might help explain some of the universe’s dark matter, although no definitive evidence has established that primordial black holes make up dark matter. Why are they relevant to fragmentation? Their formation mechanisms could potentially produce black holes with very high initial spins, including configurations much closer to the theoretical extremal limit than those commonly expected from ordinary astrophysical evolution.
The researchers therefore identify primordial black holes as particularly interesting candidates for further investigation. However, smaller does not automatically mean more likely to split. The outcome depends on the object’s mass, angular momentum, the gravitational theory being considered and the physical conditions of the proposed fragmentation process.
Could a splitting black hole produce gamma rays?
Perhaps the most exciting question is whether we could ever observe such an event. If a black hole fragmented and produced a sufficiently small black hole, the resulting object could potentially evaporate through Hawking radiation. First proposed by Stephen Hawking in 1974, this theoretical process predicts that black holes can emit radiation because of quantum effects near their horizons.
Over extremely long periods, a black hole can lose mass through this emission. The effect is negligible for large astrophysical black holes, whose predicted temperatures are extraordinarily low. Smaller black holes, however, would be considerably hotter and could evaporate much more rapidly.
As their evaporation progresses, they could release increasingly energetic radiation, potentially including gamma rays. This creates an interesting observational possibility. Instead of trying to detect the fragmentation event directly, astronomers might search for the radiation produced by the evaporation of one of its small fragments.
Two instruments are particularly relevant to this discussion:
Fermi-LAT (Large Area Telescope): NASA’s space-based gamma-ray instrument, which surveys high-energy gamma rays across the sky.
H.E.S.S.: The High Energy Stereoscopic System, an observatory in Namibia designed to detect very-high-energy gamma rays.
Both are relevant to searches for high-energy astrophysical phenomena, although neither has confirmed gamma-ray emission from black hole fragmentation. There is also a challenge involving gravitational waves. A fragmentation event producing a very small black hole could generate a gravitational-wave signal too weak to be detected by current instruments.
For this reason, the researchers consider gamma-ray observations a potentially more promising route, particularly if the event occurs relatively close to Earth or produces many small fragments. At present, this remains a prediction to investigate rather than an established detection strategy.
What about the black holes we already observe?
The universe contains black holes with impressive rotational speeds. Some supermassive black holes, located at the centres of galaxies, are believed to rotate very close to their theoretical maximum. However, reaching the exact extremal limit is a different matter. A classic study by physicist Kip Thorne, published in The Astrophysical Journal in 1974, showed that under the assumptions of a standard thin accretion disk, radiation captured by a black hole limits the maximum dimensionless spin to approximately:
a โ 0.998*
Here, a* represents the black hole’s dimensionless spin parameter. A value of 1 corresponds to the idealised extremal Kerr limit.
This is known as the Thorne limit. It is not a universal restriction for every possible black hole formation or accretion scenario, but it illustrates why astrophysical black holes may have difficulty reaching the extreme rotational conditions relevant to fragmentation. The researchers suggest that exceptional environments, including the complex dynamics surrounding black hole mergers, could deserve further attention.
Beyond Einstein: could gravity itself hold the answer?
The study goes further than examining rapidly rotating black holes within conventional general relativity. The authors also investigate other theoretical possibilities, including higher-dimensional gravitational models and scenarios involving instabilities associated with superradiance. One example is the Gregory-Laflamme instability, a phenomenon known from higher-dimensional gravity in which certain extended black-hole-like objects can become unstable and develop non-uniform structures.
The researchers also consider models that modify the relationship between black hole mass, horizon size and entropy. These approaches are important because they explore whether the restrictions imposed by familiar four-dimensional general relativity could change under different assumptions about gravity. They do not establish that such alternative gravitational scenarios describe our universe. Rather, they help physicists identify where the boundaries of existing theories might lie.
The next challenge is to understand the dynamics of fragmentation itself, calculate how likely it could be in different models and determine what observational signals it might produce.
A new question about the life of black holes
For decades, black holes have been associated with cosmic destruction, gravitational collapse and spectacular mergers. The possibility that one might split into smaller objects adds a new dimension to that picture. But the real significance of this research is not that scientists have discovered black holes breaking apart. It is that physicists are beginning to examine, with greater precision, the conditions under which an event once considered essentially forbidden might become possible.
If tiny black holes can emerge from such processes, their eventual evaporation could offer a new way to investigate Hawking radiation, primordial black holes and the limits of Einstein’s theory of gravity. For now, the universe has not revealed whether black holes can truly wear trousers. But the question is no longer just an imaginative thought experiment. It has become a subject of serious mathematical investigationโand one that future observations may eventually help us explore.
Explore More on Zemeghub
The mysteries of black holes are closely connected to the evolution and structure of the Universe. Continue exploring the cosmos with these related Zemeghub stories:
The Expanding Universe: How Cosmic Expansion Shapes Space, Time, and Dark Energy โ Discover how cosmic expansion, spacetime and dark energy shape the evolution of our Universe.
Universe 2D Map: The Extraordinary Cosmic Chart Revealing 4 Billion Celestial Objects โ Explore the remarkable cosmic map revealing billions of stars and galaxies across the observable Universe.
